Many dog owners assume clickers are essential for proper dog training. They’re everywhere in dog training videos, online tutorials, and local training classes. It’s easy to believe that without this small plastic tool, you’re somehow doing training wrong.
But after working with thousands of dogs over the years, we’ve discovered something surprising: clickers often create more problems than they solve for the average pet owner.
When we first started our training business, we did what most trainers do—we recommended clickers and taught clients how to use them. But we noticed a pattern emerging. During follow-up sessions, the clickers were nowhere to be found. When asked, owners would sheepishly admit:
“I lost it somewhere in the house.”
“I forgot to bring it on our walks.”
“My husband doesn’t use it, so the dog gets confused.”
This led us to question whether clickers were truly serving our clients’ needs or simply adding an unnecessary complication to their training process.
The most powerful training tool you have is something you’ll never forget at home: your voice. It’s always with you, requires no extra equipment, and can convey both timing and emotion effectively.
When you use a consistent marker word like “Yes!” or “Good!” in the same way you would use a clicker, your dog learns just as quickly. Plus, your voice naturally carries information about how pleased you are, adding an emotional component that strengthens your bond.
Picture this common scenario we’ve witnessed countless times: A client is holding their dog’s leash in one hand, treats in a pocket, trying to manage the dog’s behavior while simultaneously reaching for a clicker. By the time they’ve found the clicker, the perfect training moment has passed.
For most families, we observe immediate issues when trying to incorporate clickers:
The simple truth is that for 99.9% of dog owners, a clicker becomes just an extra trinket that won’t get used consistently. And inconsistency is the enemy of effective dog training.
Are there situations where clickers make sense? Absolutely. Professional trainers working on precise behaviors for service dogs, movie animals, or competition can benefit from the mechanical precision of a clicker.
But for teaching your family pet to come when called, walk nicely on leash, or stop jumping on guests? Your voice works perfectly—and you’ll never leave it sitting on the kitchen counter.
Our approach to training is built around what actually works in busy households with real families. We’ve found that the simpler we make our training methods, the more likely clients are to use them consistently. And consistency is what ultimately creates well-behaved dogs.
When we eliminated the clicker from our training protocols, we noticed something interesting: compliance with training homework increased significantly. Without the barrier of needing a special tool, clients trained more frequently and saw faster results.
The best training method isn’t necessarily the most technical one—it’s the one you’ll actually use every day. By removing unnecessary complications, we’ve helped thousands of dogs and their families achieve better results with less frustration.
The proof is in our results. Our simplified, clicker-free approach has successfully transformed the behavior of thousands of dogs, from minor issues like pulling on leash to serious aggression cases.
We’ve found that when clients focus on clear communication, consistent boundaries, and positive reinforcement delivered with their voice, they create stronger relationships with their dogs and achieve lasting behavioral changes.
After all, the goal isn’t to become the most technical trainer possible—it’s to build a wonderful life with your well-behaved dog.
Want to see how effective our clicker-free training approach can be? We’d love to show you the difference simplicity can make in your dog’s behavior and your relationship.
Dog Training Matchmaker Quiz
What type of training does your dog really need?